Why carry out an internal audit?
REDcert scheme documents require internal control of the system. Above all, though, an internal audit is a risk management tool. It finds errors before the certification body does. A non-conformity found internally costs far less than one in the certification audit report.
An external internal auditor sees the system with fresh eyes. Staff used to their procedures often miss gaps, while an experienced auditor knows which areas certification bodies examine most closely.
What we check
| Area | Typical audit questions |
|---|---|
| Documentation | Are procedures current and aligned with the valid version of the scheme documents? |
| Suppliers | Did all suppliers hold valid certificates or self-declarations on the delivery date? |
| Receipts | Does every sustainable delivery have a declaration and transport document? |
| Mass balance | Was the balance never negative, and are conversion factors justified? |
| GHG | Are sales declaration values covered by purchase values and calculations? |
| Sales | Do declarations contain all required data and a valid certificate number? |
| UDB | Does Union Database data match documents and the mass balance? |
| Staff | Are responsible people trained and do they know their tasks? |
| Corrective actions | Were previous non-conformities effectively closed? |
How the internal audit works
- Preparation. We agree scope, sites and the audit plan and request documents and a transaction list for a chosen period.
- Document review. We check procedures, registers and declaration templates.
- On-site or remote audit. We interview staff, observe processes and verify records, tracing a sample of transactions from purchase to sale.
- Mass balance and GHG verification. We recalculate the balance for selected periods and check emission value attribution.
- Closing meeting. We discuss findings with management.
- Report. We deliver a report with non-conformities, observations and recommendations.
An audit of a trader without storage usually takes one day. A processing unit with GHG calculations needs two or three days, including desk work.
Audit report and corrective actions
The report grades findings by severity. A major non-conformity means a risk that the certificate will be refused, for example a negative mass balance. A minor non-conformity is an isolated lapse that does not undermine the system's credibility. Observations point to areas for improvement.
For each non-conformity we propose a corrective action and help carry out a root cause analysis so the problem does not recur. You receive an action plan with deadlines and owners.
Internal audit versus certification audit
An internal audit does not replace the certification body's audit and does not lead to a certificate. It is, however, a good simulation, because we use similar methods: transaction sampling, balance recalculation and evidence verification.
For impartiality, the same person cannot both advise a company and audit it on behalf of a certification body. Quality Assurance Poland works solely on the client's side as consultant and internal auditor.
When to carry out an internal audit
- before the first certification audit, once the system has been running for a few weeks,
- before recertification, ideally two or three months in advance,
- after REDcert scheme document or legislative changes,
- after changes to processes, sites, ERP or key staff,
- after a complaint or a signal of possible irregularities in the chain.
Transaction sampling — how we do it
An audit cannot cover every transaction, so we take a sample across periods, suppliers, products and customers. We always add unusual transactions: large volumes, new suppliers, corrections and returns, where errors most often hide.
For each sampled transaction we trace the full path: order, transport document, supplier declaration, goods-in, mass balance entry, sales declaration and invoice. We compare quantities, dates, certificate numbers and GHG values and record discrepancies with evidence.
REDcert risk matrix
Before the audit we assess which areas are most exposed to errors, considering feedstock type, number of suppliers, process complexity and non-conformity history.
| Risk area | Example | Risk level |
|---|---|---|
| Wastes and residues | UCO from many small collectors | high |
| Farm suppliers | self-declarations without field data | medium to high |
| Mass balance | multiple sites, manual workbooks | medium |
| GHG | actual calculations at a plant | high |
| Sales | manually completed declarations | medium |
We increase the sample in high-risk areas, as certification bodies do.
Internal auditor competence
An internal auditor should know REDcert requirements, mass balance rules and GHG methodology, be able to evaluate evidence and describe non-conformities clearly, and be independent of the audited area. The person who keeps the mass balance should not audit it.
Our audits are carried out by an auditor experienced in biomass and fuel certification schemes. Reports are available in Polish or English.
Examples of internal audit findings
| Finding | Classification | Proposed action |
|---|---|---|
| Supplier certificate expired two weeks before delivery | major non-conformity | correct batch status, automatic expiry reminders |
| Sales declaration without feedstock country of origin | minor non-conformity | fix template in sales system, pre-dispatch check |
| Conversion factor not justified | minor non-conformity | derive factor from production data, document method |
| New warehouse operator's training not recorded | observation | complete training and register |
Such a summary lets management quickly assess the system and set priorities.
Tools for self-auditing
Companies with their own auditors can use the REDcert Internal Audit Toolkit. It contains audit questions, an auditor checklist, report template, corrective action plan and risk matrix. Internal auditor training is part of our REDcert training.
Frequently asked questions
Is an internal audit mandatory under REDcert?
Scheme documents require system oversight and corrective actions, and an internal audit is the most effective way to meet that requirement. Certification body auditors usually ask for internal audit results. Without such control the system looks less credible.
Who can carry out the internal audit?
Someone competent in REDcert requirements and ideally independent of the audited area. Small companies often choose an external auditor. Document the auditor's competence and base the report on evidence.
How much does an internal audit cost?
It depends on the number of audit days, which depends on scope and sites. A trader audit is usually one day. A processing unit needs more time to verify mass balance and GHG. We quote after a short interview.
Can the audit be done remotely?
Yes, the document and transaction part can be done remotely. Inspecting a warehouse or plant usually needs a visit or video link. For traders a remote audit is often sufficient. We agree the format in the audit plan.
What will we receive after the audit?
A report listing non-conformities and observations with evidence and recommendations, plus a corrective action plan with deadlines. On request we verify the effectiveness of actions afterwards. The report can be shown to the certification body auditor.
Does the audit cover GHG calculations?
Yes, if you pass on emission values. We check input data, the calculation method and attribution to batches, and verify consistency with purchase and sales declarations. GHG errors are among the most serious non-conformities.
How should we prepare for the internal audit?
Make available current procedures, registers, a transaction list and the mass balance for a chosen period. Ensure the people responsible for purchasing, warehouse and sales are present. We send a document list in advance.
Can the internal audit cover several schemes?
Yes, we can combine REDcert-EU, REDcert², ISCC and KZR INiG. Common areas are checked once and scheme-specific requirements separately, which shortens the audit. The report states which scheme each finding relates to.
Sources and reference documents
- REDcert GmbH — scheme documents and certificate list
- EUR-Lex — Directive (EU) 2023/2413 (RED III)
- EUR-Lex — Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/996
This content is prepared by Quality Assurance Poland and is not a REDcert GmbH document. Always apply the current versions of REDcert scheme documents and legislation.
Enquire about this service
Briefly describe your business and certification goal, and we will propose a scope, timeline and price.