Why is mass balance so important?
In most biomass supply chains physical batch separation is impossible. Rapeseed from different farmers goes into one silo and oil from different batches into one tank. Mass balance solves this: sustainability characteristics are attributed to quantities of material rather than to specific grains or litres.
Article 30 of the RED requires recognised schemes to use mass balance. Detailed rules are set out in Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/996 and the REDcert scheme documents. Auditors always check the mass balance, because errors mean selling sustainability status without coverage.
Basic mass balance rules
- The balance is kept separately for each site and each type of material with different characteristics.
- Batches with different characteristics, such as country of origin or GHG value, may be mixed, but their characteristics are accounted for separately.
- Sustainable material delivered in a period may not exceed material received plus the balance brought forward.
- A negative balance is not allowed — it means selling a characteristic you did not have.
- Processing is reflected through conversion factors based on actual process yields.
Balancing periods
A balancing period is the time over which you reconcile receipts and deliveries. Regulation 2022/996 sets its maximum length. For agricultural and forest biomass producers and first gathering points sourcing only from them, the period can be up to 12 months. For all other operators the maximum is 3 months.
You choose the period in your procedure and apply it consistently. A shorter period, for example monthly, makes control easier and reveals errors faster. At the end of a period a positive balance can be carried forward if it matches the physical stock in the warehouse.
Conversion factors and co-products
A processing unit turns feedstock into main products and co-products. A tonne of rapeseed yields oil and meal; maize yields bioethanol and DDGS. The conversion factor shows how much product is obtained from a unit of feedstock. It must be based on production data and kept up to date.
| Process | Example products | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Rapeseed crushing | crude oil, meal or cake | moisture, oil content, losses |
| Transesterification | FAME, glycerine | methanol use, oil quality |
| Grain fermentation | bioethanol, DDGS | starch yield, distillation losses |
| Anaerobic digestion | biogas, biomethane, digestate | substrate mix, storage emissions |
A factor set too high leads to selling status without coverage; one set too low means losing product value. We help determine factors and document the method.
Mass balance and GHG values
Under REDcert-EU every batch carries a GHG value, so the mass balance must account for GHG characteristics as well as quantities. Batches with different emission values can be tracked separately, or outgoing batches can be assigned the least favourable value. Averaging GHG values is only permitted to the extent allowed by legislation and scheme documents.
This is a frequent source of non-conformities: a company sells a batch with a better GHG value than any batch it received. Our mass balance workbooks therefore have separate emission columns and an attribution check. Calculation details are on the GHG calculations page.
Losses, corrections and stocktaking
The mass balance must reflect storage losses, weight differences and process losses. Losses reduce the quantity of sustainable material you can sell. Their level should come from measurements or documented norms.
At the end of the period we compare the book balance with the stocktake. A large discrepancy signals recording errors. The procedure must state how differences are explained and who approves corrections.
Workbook or ERP report?
Small companies often keep the balance in Excel. It is cheap and flexible but needs formula controls and protection against accidental changes. Larger companies prefer an ERP report that pulls data directly from warehouse documents.
We design both. The workbook includes balance checks, locked formulas and an auditor summary. The ERP report specification defines fields, filters and control rules. In both cases we train the people responsible.
Mass balance implementation step by step
- Flow map. We describe inputs, processes, storage and outputs for each site.
- Rules. We choose the balancing period, units, GHG accounting method and carry-over rules.
- Conversion factors. We determine them from production data.
- Tool. We build the workbook or report specification.
- Test. We reconcile data from recent months and compare it with stocktakes.
- Procedure and training. We document the rules and train the team.
Example: closing a balancing period
A rapeseed warehouse runs a quarterly balance. It starts the period with 500 tonnes of sustainable rapeseed. During the quarter it receives 4,000 tonnes with declarations and 1,500 tonnes without. It sells 3,800 tonnes with declarations and 1,900 tonnes without. Storage losses are 0.5% of receipts.
| Item | Sustainable quantity (t) |
|---|---|
| Opening balance | 500 |
| Receipts with declarations | 4,000 |
| Losses (0.5% of receipts) | −20 |
| Deliveries with declarations | −3,800 |
| Closing balance | 680 |
The closing balance of 680 tonnes can be carried forward if at least that much rapeseed is physically in stock. If the stocktake shows less, the balance must be reduced. At no point in the period may the balance fall below zero.
Mass balance across several schemes and markets
If a company holds several certificates, for example REDcert-EU and ISCC EU, the balance must show in which scheme each quantity was received and delivered. Recognised schemes may accept material from other recognised schemes on the terms set out in their scheme documents, but the same quantity can never be sold twice.
The same applies to REDcert²: sustainability status attributed to feed products cannot also be used for fuels. The workbook then has separate columns for each scheme and market, with a total check.
Frequently asked questions
Can sustainable and non-sustainable material be physically mixed under REDcert?
Yes, mass balance allows physical mixing. Sustainability characteristics are accounted for separately in your records. You cannot sell more sustainable material than you received, and every attribution must follow from records.
How long can a balancing period be?
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/996 allows up to 12 months for agricultural and forest biomass producers and first gathering points sourcing only from them. For other operators the maximum is 3 months. Shorter periods are allowed, and the choice must be documented in your procedure.
What happens to a positive balance at the end of a period?
It can be carried forward if it matches physical stock in the warehouse. If stock does not match, the balance must be corrected. Carrying forward a balance not covered by stock is a non-conformity, which is why we link period closing to stocktaking.
Can GHG values be averaged in the mass balance?
Only to the extent allowed by legislation and scheme documents. Otherwise batches with different values are accounted for separately. Assigning the least favourable value is a safe approach. The rules must be set out in your GHG procedure.
How do we determine a conversion factor?
From production data: the quantity of feedstock processed and products obtained over a representative period, adjusted for moisture and quality. Update it after process changes. The auditor compares it with production data.
Can REDcert-EU and REDcert² share one mass balance?
Physical flows are shared, but characteristics are accounted for separately per scheme. The same tonne cannot be sold with declarations under both schemes as two different characteristics. The workbook must show which scheme each quantity was attributed to.
What are the most common mass balance errors?
A negative balance at some point in the period, ignored losses and incorrect conversion factors. Unit mix-ups such as tonnes and cubic metres are also common, as is assigning GHG values without coverage. An internal audit helps catch these errors before the certification audit.
How long does mass balance implementation take?
One to three weeks for a trader or warehouse and three to six weeks for a processing unit, because conversion factors need to be determined. Timing depends on warehouse data quality. We always run a test reconciliation on real data.
Sources and reference documents
- EUR-Lex — Implementing Regulation (EU) 2022/996
- REDcert GmbH — scheme documents and certificate list
- EUR-Lex — Directive (EU) 2023/2413 (RED III)
This content is prepared by Quality Assurance Poland and is not a REDcert GmbH document. Always apply the current versions of REDcert scheme documents and legislation.
Enquire about this service
Briefly describe your business and certification goal, and we will propose a scope, timeline and price.